moving sign


***************************************************************

DN Speak has moved.


Click here to go to DN Speak 2016 for new posts.


***************************************************************


































































Featured: Interviews for the Well-Informed

Featured: Interviews for the Well-Informed

Did you know? After the last post on this page is a link to "Older posts".

Tuesday, November 18, 2014

Jonathan Figdor: Objective Morality is a Myth

Imagine a young man, let's call him Paul, living in Paris in the early days of the Nazi occupation in WWII. He lives, serving as caregiver to his ailing mother with Parkinson's disease. While she is entirely dependent on him, he loves his mother very much and is happy to care for her, just as she did for him as a child. But every day, Paul wakes up and reads the newspaper, hearing each day about the German advance. Paul dreams of joining the Resistance. He isn't Jewish himself, but he still cares for his fellow Frenchmen, regardless of their race or religion. He knows that if no one stands up to Hitler, his friends who were black, or gay, or Jewish, would be rounded up and sent to camps.

What was it Edmund Burke or John Stewart Mill who once said, "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good men do nothing?" Still, the young man knows that joining the Resistance means abandoning his ailing mother.

Put yourself in his shoes? What's the right thing to do?

Maybe there isn't always the right choice, and the wrong choice, but two good choices, or two bad choices.
http://youtu.be/fqg_xbBu3ag

No comments:

Post a Comment








Click Older Posts above to see more.





Search this blog